The Multiple Impacts of Population Displacement and the Demolition of Kirkuk Citadel (1989-1998)
Abstract
This study highlights a significant cultural and civilizational crime committed against Kirkuk Citadel. This crime began with a political decision by the Iraqi government in 1989 to displace the residents of Kirkuk Citadel under the pretext of renovation. Subsequently, another political decision was made by the former President of Iraq during his visit to Kirkuk city on March 16, 1990, to demolish the citadel. Following this decision, the local administration in the city formed a committee to expropriate residential homes and heritage buildings and displace their residents to areas outside the citadel. Later, the residential buildings and heritage sites were demolished, and funds were allocated for this process. The demolition of Kirkuk Citadel began in two phases: the first phase started in 1990, and the second phase in 1998.
This study aims to uncover the political and professional reasons and motives behind the decision to displace the residents and demolish Kirkuk Citadel. It also analyzes the role played by the policy of ethnic and cultural cleansing in this decision and its impact on human heritage, relying on official documents. The study is structured around several main axes: The first axis provides a historical overview of Kirkuk Citadel, including its historical and civilizational importance and the most prominent phases it has undergone. The second axis discusses the phase of Kirkuk Citadel's renovation and the displacement of its residents in 1989. The third axis addresses the stages of Kirkuk Citadel's demolition during the years 1990-1998 and analyzes the political and cultural motives behind the demolition process. Finally, the fourth axis examines the multiple impacts of the displacement of the citadel's residents and its demolition on the city's cultural, ethnic, and historical heritage.
References
Ahmed, J. R. (2002). Kirkuk in Ancient Times. Erbil: Aras Publishing, p.23-45.
Taha Baqir, a. F. (1959). Guide to Archaeological and Civilizational Sites, Fourth Journey. Baghdad: Ministry of
Culture and Guidance, p.8.
Francis, B. a. (1952). "A Historical Overview of the Origins and Names of Iraqi Places". Sumer Magazine(8), p. 572;
Wahbi, T. 2. (2006). The Complete Works (Vol. 1). (R. Salih, Ed.) Sulaymaniyah, p. 247-254.
Yazdi, S. A. (1336). Zafarnama. Tehran: Mohammad Abbasi, p.496.
Taha Baqir, a. F, op.cit, p.8.
Ahmed, J. R, op.cit, p.28.
Yusuf, A.R. (2009). The Demolition of Kirkuk Citadel and My Attempts to Save It. Sulaymaniyah, p.53.
Taha Baqir, a. F, op.cit, p.8.
Yusuf, A. a.-R. (2009), p.53.
Shawani, M. H. (2006). Ethnic and Religious Diversity in Kirkuk, Erbil, p.76.
Minas, R. 1. (1982, Mosul). "Kirkuk in History". Bayn al-Nahrayn Magazine, p.285.
Al-Attiya, J. (2009). Kirkuk Citadel: Its Historical Importance and Civilizational Value ,from the book Kirkuk, City of
Fraternal Nationalities. Erbil: Aras Publishing, p.169.
Yusuf, A.R.(2001, Kirkuk),Archaeological and Heritage Landmarks in Kirkuk City.Kirkuk Magazine, p.109.
Raouf, H. S. (2017). The Planning and Architecture of Kirkuk Citadel: Archaeological Civilization Field Work.
unpublished MA thesis. Erbil: College of Arts, Salahaddin University, p.23-25.
Yusuf, A.R. (2009). The Demolition of Kirkuk…, p.56.
Al-Janabi, S. H. (1977). Changes in Land Use Around the Iraqi City. unpublished PhD dissertation. Baghdad: College
of Arts, p.84.
Safar, Z. a.-A. (1987-1988). "Urban Renewal of Kirkuk Citade". Sumer Magazine, p.87-88.
Ministry of Culture and Information. (1994, December 4). Ministry of Culture and Information. to the Esteemed
Secretary of the President , Top Secret and Personal, No.(1877). Baghdad.
Amin, S. M. (2025, April 3). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Kirkuk. Retrieved from https://youtu.be/esPHCyY-a88
Republic of Iraq, Presidency Office. (1989, September 20). M/ Dur Kirkuk Citadel. 33511. Baghdad.
Ministry of Culture and Information. (1994, December 4). Ministry of Culture and Information. to the Esteemed
Secretary of the President , Top Secret and Personal, No.(1877). Baghdad.
Tamim Antiquities Inspectorate. (1989, November 26). Department of Antiquities and Heritage. to Kirkuk
Municipality Directorate/Warning Committee (M/ Kirkuk Citadel), 381. Kirkuk.
Yusuf, A.R. (2009). The Demolition of Kirkuk…, p.58.
Republic of Iraq, Tamim Governorate. (1990, March 17). Administrative Order (Secret Correspondence). 1/1756, 1-2.
Kirkuk, p.1-2.
Ibid, p.1-2.
Department of Antiquities and Heritage, Tamim Antiquities Inspectorate. (1990, August 31).
Amin, S. M. (2025, April 3). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Kirkuk. Retrieved from https://youtu.be/esPHCyY-a88
Hassan, A.-R. Y. (2025, March 8). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Sulaymaniyah. https://youtu.be/GYTGZymPxyg
General Establishment for Communications and Post. (1990, December 8). A letter from Abd al-Raqeeb Yusuf
Hassan to the Office of President Saddam Hussein. 524, 1-4. Sulaymaniyah, p.1-3.
Republic of Iraq, Presidency Office. (1990, December 8). M/Abd al-Raqeeb Yusuf Hassan. 1889. Baghdad.
Ibid.
Ministry of Culture and Information, Department of Antiquities and Heritage. (1990, December 13). to the
Presidency Office (M/ Abd al-Raqeeb Yusuf Hassan's Report). 1/ 1/ 1/ 385. Baghdad.
Yusuf, A.R. (2009). The Demolition of Kirkuk…, p.59.
Republic of Iraq, Kirkuk Governorate.(1991, November 11).To the Ministry of Interior (M/ Kirkuk Citadel).
/7/2/2/537. Kirkuk.
Ministry of Culture and Information. (1994, December 4). Ministry of Culture and Information. to the Esteemed
Secretary of the President , Top Secret and Personal, No.(1877). Baghdad.
Ibid.
Republic of Iraq, Ministry of Interior. (1993, September 8). To Tamim Governorate (M/ Kirkuk Citadel Project
Development). 3/ 13/ 260. Baghdad.
Republic of Iraq, Ministry of Interior. (1993, June 4). To the General Directorate of Municipalities. 386. Baghdad.
Ministry of Culture and Information. (1994, December 4). Ministry of Culture and Information. to the Esteemed
Secretary of the President , Top Secret and Personal, No.(1877). Baghdad.
Republic of Iraq, Ministry of Interior. (1993, September 8). To Tamim Governorate (M/ Kirkuk Citadel Project
Development). 3/ 13/ 260. Baghdad.
Republic of Iraq, Tamim Governorate. (1998, May 23). To the Presidency Diwan (M/ Allocation of Funds). 2103.
Kirkuk.
Sawt al-Tamim Newspaper. (1998). Sawt al-Tamim Newspaper(6-7), p.1.
Yusuf, A.R. (2009). The Demolition of Kirkuk…, p.59.
Ministry of Culture and Information, Department of Antiquities and Heritage. (1998, May 5). To the Governorate of
Tamim (M/ Kirkuk Citadel). 1096. Baghdad, p.1-2.
Ministry of Culture and Information, Department of Antiquities and Heritage. (1998, September 6). To Tamim
Governorate (M/ Storage of Reinforcing Steel). 3775. Baghdad.
Republic of Iraq, Ministry of Endowments and Religious Affairs, Department of Religious Institutions. (1998, August
. To the Department of Antiquities and Heritage (M/ Shrine of Hassan Maki). 3258. Baghdad.
Ahmed, J. R, op.cit, p.45.
Hassan, A.-R. Y. (2025, March 8). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Sulaymaniyah. Retrieved from
Oglu, N. K. (2025, March 11). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Kirkuk. Retrieved from https://youtu.be/pso4XILhts4
Sumer Magazine. (2007, April). Sumer Magazine, p. 38.
Salih, H. A. (2008). The Arabization Policy in Kirkuk City. Sulaymaniyah: Kurdistan Strategic Center, p.261-264.
Hassan, A.-R. Y. (2025, March 8). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Sulaymaniyah. https://youtu.be/GYTGZymPxyg
Al-Hadidi Y.A.(2025, February 26). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Kirkuk. https://youtu.be/jdhZoNWNGk8
Ibid.
Bahrooz, S. B. (2025, March 19). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Sulaymaniyah. https://youtu.be/yi7MjmlB2SM
Oglu, N. K. (2025, March 11). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Kirkuk. Retrieved from https://youtu.be/pso4XILhts4
Hassan, A.-R. Y. (2025, March 8). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Sulaymaniyah. Retrieved from
Ministry of Interior, Tamim Governorate. (1991, October 13). To the Department of Antiquities and Heritage (M/
Kirkuk Citadel). 4253. Kirkuk.
Yusuf, A.R. (2009). The Demolition of Kirkuk…, p.116.
Ibid, p.117.
Ibid, p.153.
Ministry of Interior, Tamim Governorate. (1991, October 13). To the Department of Antiquities and Heritage (M/
Kirkuk Citadel). 4253. Kirkuk.
Republic of Iraq, Presidency Office. (1993, June 24). To the Ministry of Interior (M/ Kirkuk Citadel). 17083. Baghdad.
Bahrooz, S. B. (2025, March 19). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Sulaymaniyah. https://youtu.be/yi7MjmlB2SM
Oglu, N. K. (2025, March 11). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Kirkuk. Retrieved from https://youtu.be/pso4XILhts4
Mohammed, A. M. (2025, April 9). Kirkuk. Retrieved from https://youtu.be/qb0aQ4-Zxiw
Elias, L. B. (2025, June 21). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Kirkuk. Retrieved from https://youtu.be/IScULTe6acw
Oglu, N. K. (2025, March 11). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Kirkuk. Retrieved from https://youtu.be/pso4XILhts4
Salih, A. O. (2025, April 16). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Kirkuk. https://youtu.be/iRO0pCKUXZA
Qalali, I. (2025, June 3). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Kirkuk. Retrieved from https://youtu.be/LkLBFY7KRsg
Baha El-Din , Y. A.-D. (2025, June 14). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Kirkuk. Retrieved from
Mohammed, A. M. (2025, April 9). Kirkuk. Retrieved from https://youtu.be/qb0aQ4-Zxiw
Darwish, N. (2025, June 15). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Retrieved from https://youtu.be/_zJXKMbNdoc
Amin, S. M. (2025, April 3). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Kirkuk. Retrieved from https://youtu.be/esPHCyY-a88
Abdullah, S. M. (2015, June 14). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Retrieved from https://youtu.be/QOJcEC0YIeY
Mohammed, A. M. (2025, April 9). Kirkuk. Retrieved from https://youtu.be/qb0aQ4-Zxiw
Salih, A. O. (2025, April 16). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Kirkuk. https://youtu.be/iRO0pCKUXZA
Shaida, S. (2025, May 31). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Retrieved from https://youtu.be/flwq3sh_xXA
Darwish, N. (2025, June 15). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Retrieved from https://youtu.be/_zJXKMbNdoc
Baha El-Din , Y. A.-D. (2025, June 14). (D. O. Abdul Aziz, Interviewer) Kirkuk. Retrieved from